Italian restaurants

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant

4.5 1,239 reviews 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM 351 W Main St, New Holland, PA 17557, United States

Discover this place

Welcome to Palermo Pizza Italian Restaurant, where quality and tradition blend seamlessly to create an unforgettable dining experience. Nestled in New Holland, PA, we take pride in offering an extensive menu featuring specialty pizzas like our Penne Al Pesto and Stuffed Meat Pizza, all crafted with fresh ingredients and a passion for authentic Italian cuisine. Our welcoming atmosphere, combined with attentive service, ensures a satisfying meal that exceeds expectations. Whether you're enjoying a casual lunch or a gathering with friends, our generous portions and affordable prices make Palermo a cherished local gem. Join us and savor the flavors that keep our community coming back for more!

Photos

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Photo 1

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Photo 2

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Photo 3

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Photo 4

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant - Photo 5

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant

4.5

1,239 reviews

100%

24%

Review highlights

Based on 1,239 reviews

Palermo Pizza & Italian Restaurant in New Holland consistently receives positive feedback for its generous portions, reasonable pricing, and friendly, attentive service. Customers appreciate the variety of pizza options available, with particular praise for the Sicilian pizza's light, fluffy texture and crisp base. The restaurant is noted for its warm, casual atmosphere and quick service, even during busy lunch hours. While some reviews mention that the flavors lean more toward American-style Italian rather than authentic Italian, the overall quality and value keep guests returning. Sub sandwiches and other menu items also receive commendations for taste and size. Staff friendliness and efficient service are commonly highlighted as key strengths.

Brian Ducharme

Apr 20, 2025

Great spot for lunch. They have a good variety of pizza on display to choose from.They were very friendly and hard working. Very busy at lunch but people were served quickly. I had a slice of the Sicilian pizza and a meat roll. Both were excellent and very reasonably priced. Definitely will go back

Woodzy fox

Apr 17, 2025

Went here to meet some friend's.The food was just amazing and so filling for the size that you get. I got a small parm and it looked like a large with extra chicken!! Next time in the area we will 100% have to stop by again!Thank you staff for the amazing food

RICHARD LAROCCO

Apr 13, 2025

Great food and service with and amazing value!!!! The Sicilian pizza is light and Fluffy with a crisp bottom. A real hidden gem!!

Heisenberg

Mar 02, 2025

The pizza here is good and cheap. Also large servings for food. The waitress is fast and courteous, food always comes out hot.They have the best bread for their subs that I've found in the New Holland/Leola/Brownstown area. 10.06 for a Large Italian ain't bad either. It's enough to split between two people.

K L

Feb 17, 2025

It is a casual restaurant. Our waitress, Becky, is one of the best waitresses that have served us for a while. Becky paid attention to our needs, suggested options, smiled a lot, seemed like was having fun, constantly was cleaning the table and made our night special.The taste of all the food was good. It does not have the same Italian taste as genuine pizza or pasta but to be an American Italian restaurant, it was good.The portions of the food was super decent, one plate can serve two people.I would definitely come back again.

Heide Dudden

Feb 09, 2025

Been eating here since they opened & were a little spot called Nino's! Portions have always stayed consistent. If u leave still hungry then make sure you order more than a slice! Go at lunchtime & the stuffed pizzas & other options are amazing as well.

Esther Stoltzfus

Jan 01, 2025

We were here on a Monday night, it wasn’t full at all, and the place was pretty quiet. The food was delicious! We had a 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 Supreme pizza and the Supreme is “loaded” and they have great hot wings too.

Jefry Rivera

Dec 31, 2024

Pizzas are really good. I tried the pasta salad for the first time, and it was really good. There's always screaming and craziness in the kitchen, some people don't like that but I think that's what it makes it an authentic pizza shop.